Hi Casey,
Could someone with some time please provide me with STEP by STEP instructions
I'm not sure if I know the best way to do this, but what I do is:
1) copy the quote (select the text from the original message which is below the Post Reply input box, then control-C)
2) paste it to where I want it in the Post Reply box (select the location then Control-V)
3) select the quote text in the post reply box
4) hit the Quote Selection button on the post reply toolbar, it has a picture of upper and lower double quotes
Good luck with it
Todd